Questions you can’t ask in a Job Interview (…
SMTP HD › Blog › Questions you can’t ask in a Job Interview (…

Questions you can’t ask in a Job Interview (and what to ask instead)

•June 16, 2025•2 min read
Pixelated 1980s photo of a brass padlock on a closed folder in a meeting room

Hiring in the U.S.? Exciting! But if you're still asking candidates what year they graduated or if they have kids, stop.

Here’s a quick list of what’s off-limits in the U.S., and what you can ask instead.

❌ Off-Limits

Age

  • Don’t ask: “How old are you?” or “When did you graduate?”
  • Why? Age Discrimination in Employment Act (40+ protected).

Marital & Parental Status

  • Don’t ask: “Are you married?” “Any kids?” “Planning to have kids?”
  • Why? Title VII. It’s none of your business, and yes, it’s illegal.

Religion

  • Don’t ask: “Do you go to church?” “What holidays do you celebrate?”
  • Why? Protected under federal law. You don’t need to know.

Citizenship

  • Don’t ask: “Are you a U.S. citizen?”
  • Ask instead: “Are you authorized to work in the U.S.?”

Disability or Medical Conditions

  • Don’t ask: “Do you have any health issues we should know about?”
  • Why? ADA. You can only ask after a job offer—if you ask everyone.

Criminal Record (Too Soon)

  • Don’t ask: “Have you ever been arrested?”
  • Why? Ban-the-box laws in many states. You can ask about convictions only after you’ve made a conditional offer or at the interview stage—depending on local law.

Race, Gender Identity, Sexual Orientation, or Genetic Info

  • Just don’t. No upside, all risk.

✅ What You Can Ask

  • “Are you legally authorized to work in the U.S.?”
  • “Can you travel 25% of the time?”
  • “This role requires lifting 25 lbs, can you do that with or without accommodation?”
  • “Have you ever been convicted of a felony directly related to this role?” (only when compliant)

If your hiring team is winging interviews without proper training, you’re one awkward question away from a lawsuit.

Train your team. Stick to role-relevant questions. And if you’re not sure, don’t ask.

Victor Vatus
Founder, Sell Me This Pen

Victor opened the US market for a French company, closing the first 15 accounts himself before hiring the team, then turned that craft into Sell Me This Pen. He has since done it for hundreds of companies coming from Europe and beyond.

Hiring sales talent in the US or Canada?No retainer. Pay when they join.

Plan your next hire
SMTP HD › Blog2 min read